Beethoven: Piano Trio No. 1 in E-Flat, Op. 1, No. 1; Piano Trio No. 5 in D ("Ghost"), Op. 70, No. 1; Schöne Minka, ich muss scheiden, WoO 158a, No. 16 (arr. Enders). Sitkovetsky Trio. BIS-2699.
This release concludes BIS's recent series of Beethoven piano trios. It features the somewhat unusual pairing of his 'official' first work in the genre and his fifth. (I've always thought the "Ghost" appellation for the latter ridiculous in terms of what happens in the second movement!) Both trios are prime Beethoven, though I continue to harbor special fondness for the Op. 1 set. Also included is an arrangement by the group's cellist, Isang Enders, of Schöne Minka, ich muss scheiden, from the WoO 158 songs of different nationalities.
The Sitkovetsky Trio (ostensibly named after the group's violinist, Alexander Sitkovetsky) brings admirable energy to their performances, and especially crackling virtuosity from pianist Wu Qian. These interpretations are full of spirit and warmth. There's nothing eccentric here - no doing weird stuff in an attempt to stand out. (This is a refreshing change of pace from certain other listening experiences lately!) What we have are just three earnest, skilled musicians doing right by the music. I guess if I had to point out some flaws, I'd begin by wishing for a bit richer tone from the string players. Sometimes they sound slightly on the meek side, especially next to the torrid piano playing. Also, while the pep in the finale of Op. 1/1 is nice, perhaps the tempo there is a bit much. Occasionally some of the smaller details sounded obscured.
But even in a crowded field these are fine performances. Anyone coming to this music for the first time will be well served, though I would encourage such listeners to soon explore further.
Recommended
No comments:
Post a Comment